Understanding trading edge and risk
Two ideas I'm trying to understand as a beginner: whether a strategy has an advantage, and how much it can lose.
A captured spark. Unverified, unpolished, possibly wrong.
When I first think about trading, it’s tempting to imagine the main task is knowing where the market will go next. The more useful questions for me as a beginner are how to tell whether a strategy has an advantage and what happens when its trades go badly.
Predictions can be part of a strategy, but a prediction on its own doesn’t tell me whether the trade is worthwhile. I also need to consider the possible gain, the possible loss, and the costs of making the trade.
What an edge would mean
A simple example is a hypothetical bet that wins one unit 52% of the time and loses one unit 48% of the time. Before costs, its expected return is positive. That doesn’t tell me what will happen on the next attempt, and it doesn’t guarantee a profit over any particular number of attempts.
Real trading is more difficult to describe. Wins and losses can be different sizes, costs reduce returns, and the conditions that made a strategy work may change. A high win rate can still lose money if the losses are large enough.
So when I say “edge”, I mean a reason to expect positive returns after accounting for those things, supported by evidence I can examine. Finding a nice-looking pattern in past data isn’t enough to establish it.
How much can go wrong?
Even if a strategy has an advantage, taking too much risk can produce losses I can’t afford to continue through. Position sizing matters, as do leverage, liquidity, and the possibility that several positions lose together.
This connects with the Kelly criterion, which made me interested in how assumptions about odds affect the amount someone chooses to risk. A formula is only useful if the inputs and the situation justify it, and mine aren’t reliable enough to treat as trading instructions.
The market also changes as other people respond to it. That’s one of the reasons it interests me as a system with competing participants, rather than a puzzle with a permanent solution waiting to be found.
For my own learning plan, I’d like to practise explaining where a proposed advantage comes from, how I’d test it, and what would make me stop believing in it. I’m still at the stage of learning to ask those questions, without putting money behind my answers.
Paths that lead here
- How much time should I give a bug hunt? · It also connects with my notes on trading and risk, where the quality of an estimate matters just as much as knowing the formula.
- Learning about quant trading · I'm keeping my notes on edge and risk alongside this plan so I can return to the basic questions when the charts get distracting.
Where this note points
- How much time should I give a bug hunt? · I'm wondering whether the Kelly criterion can help me think about research time, and where that comparison breaks down.
- Thinking like an attacker · I'm interested in the gap between how a system is supposed to work and what its parts allow it to do.
- Learning about quant trading · I want to learn the maths and testing behind trading, while keeping real money out of the experiment.
More from these beds
- The birthday paradox · Why just 23 people are enough for a roughly even chance of a shared birthday.
- Thinking about right and wrong · The Good Place got me thinking about outcomes, intentions, and how we decide what a good action looks like.