Skip to content

Thinking about right and wrong

The Good Place got me thinking about outcomes, intentions, and how we decide what a good action looks like.

planted June 19, 2026 · last tended November 9, 2026

A captured spark. Unverified, unpolished, possibly wrong.


I’ve been watching The Good Place, and its points system is a very entertaining way to become uncomfortable about your own decisions. Imagine every action contributing to a score you can’t see, under rules nobody has fully explained to you.

Buying a friend a mango seems like it ought to count in your favour. Being needlessly cruel seems like it should count against you. Once the examples get more complicated, though, it’s harder to agree about what we’re measuring.

That’s where I start getting interested in ethics, the part of philosophy concerned with how we should act. Different approaches pay attention to different parts of a decision, and I’m trying to understand what each helps us notice.

Three ways of approaching a decision

Consequentialism judges actions by their consequences. If I’m deciding between two options, I need to consider what each is likely to do to the people affected. Utilitarianism is one influential version, usually concerned with overall well-being. One difficulty is that I rarely know all the consequences in advance.

Deontology gives an important role to duties, rights, and constraints on how we treat people. A good outcome doesn’t automatically justify every way of reaching it. Different versions disagree about which duties apply and how to handle conflicts between them, so it’s more complicated than a list of rules that never needs interpretation.

Virtue ethics asks about character and practical judgement. What would an honest, kind, or courageous person notice in this situation, and what habits am I developing through my choices? I like how that brings attention to patterns of behaviour over time.

These are broad introductions, and each contains plenty of disagreement. I don’t think choosing a label would save me from having to think carefully about a particular situation.

The examples that make it harder

Moral luck is one problem I keep coming back to. Imagine two people who both text while driving. One gets home without hurting anyone, while the other causes a crash because someone happens to be in the way.

Both took a similar risk, but the consequences are very different. It seems reasonable to care about the harm, while also recognising that the first driver wasn’t necessarily making a better decision. I’m not sure there’s a simple way to make those judgements line up.

Motivation complicates things too. If I help a friend partly because I want to be seen as helpful, does that reduce the value of what I did? The friend may still benefit, even if I’m disappointed by what I notice about my own reasons.

That makes the show’s neat scoreboard feel less like an answer and more like a starting point. In real life, I have to consider what happened, what I could reasonably have known, and how I treated the people involved. I’d like to get better at considering those things without pretending they always produce one obvious result.

Paths that lead here

  • Getting into philosophy · I've started exploring that through a note about right and wrong, prompted by watching The Good Place.

Where this note points

  • Getting into philosophy · A few questions that make philosophy feel relevant to everyday life, and the areas I'd like to understand better.

More from these beds