Why searching online feels tiring
It takes effort to find a useful answer when so many pages sound helpful without telling you very much.
A captured spark. Unverified, unpolished, possibly wrong.
You can search for something fairly simple and still end up opening several pages before finding an answer. A question about boiling an egg becomes an introduction to the history of breakfast, while a search for a software vulnerability leads to articles that repeat the same description without helping you work out whether you’re affected.
I find that frustrating partly because the individual pages don’t always look obviously bad. They have a relevant heading, a confident introduction, and plenty of words about the subject. It’s only after reading for a while that I realise they haven’t answered the question.
That was what interested me in Maggie Appleton’s writing about AI-generated content. The problem goes beyond whether a sentence is factually wrong. A page can be plausible and readable while giving very little thought to what the reader actually needs.
The work of finding something useful
Information Foraging Theory, developed by Peter Pirolli and Stuart Card, offers a useful way to think about searching. It draws a comparison between looking for information and looking for food: we follow clues about where something useful might be and decide whether to keep looking in one place or move on.
Those clues are sometimes called information scent. A clear title, a promising excerpt, or a familiar source can help us decide which link to follow.
The difficulty comes when a page is good at looking relevant but doesn’t deliver much once we arrive. I have to read enough to recognise that, go back to the results, and make another choice. Repeating that process is work, even if each individual click takes very little time.
I think this explains part of why a short search can feel tiring, although it isn’t a complete explanation for every distracted afternoon. There are plenty of reasons attention might be difficult on a particular day.
Low-effort AI content can make the problem worse because it makes plausible text cheap to produce. But the problem didn’t begin with AI, and knowing how a page was written doesn’t settle whether it’s useful. What I want is an answer from someone who has checked the details and considered the question.
What this means for my own writing
There’s an uncomfortable part to this: I want to publish, so I need to ask whether my own notes are adding anything useful. It’s easy to complain about repetitive explanations and then write another one because I like the subject.
I don’t think I need an entirely original idea every time. A clear example, an account of what I tried, or an explanation of where I got stuck could still help someone. I do need to be able to say what the piece contributes.
That question is more useful than deciding the internet already has enough writing and giving up. It also gives me a practical response to the worry that I’m only sounding informed: include the reasoning and the sources, and let the reader see what I’ve actually done.
The broader feeling that the internet is becoming less personal is part of this too. I’d like these notes to give someone a reason to trust a particular explanation, rather than ask them to trust it because it sounds confident.
Paths that lead here
- Getting comfortable sharing my thoughts · With so much generic explanation already available, the part I can contribute is how I'm working through it, including where I'm still getting stuck.
- Why the internet sometimes feels fake · Generative AI adds another way to produce large amounts of plausible material, which is one reason I've been thinking about how much effort it takes to find something useful.
- Worrying about sounding smart · I notice the same problem when reading confident but unhelpful articles online.
Where this note points
- Worrying about sounding smart · I sometimes worry that I've learned the vocabulary of an idea before I've really understood it.
- Why the internet sometimes feels fake · Bots and repetitive content can make the web feel strange, but I don't want suspicion to become my default response to everyone.
More from these beds
- Getting into philosophy · A few questions that make philosophy feel relevant to everyday life, and the areas I'd like to understand better.
- How I think about this site's security · What I want to protect on this site, the choices I've made, and the risks that still need attention.
- Learning in public · Why I'm sharing unfinished notes, even when I'm a little embarrassed by them.
- Learning to explain things better · Someone told me I wasn't a good explainer, and it made me think about how often I talk past people.